The J.M. Smucker Company (SJM) — RQD Stock Rating Cockpit

Per the Roarable RQD rating, SJM scores 55 out of 100, a letter grade of D+, with the verdict "Roarable Sell — Weak Fundamentals / Trim." The score is built from five pillars, each out of 20:

• Fundamental Cash Engine: 8 / 20. The rating cites ROIC of 2.8% and an FCF yield of 8.57%. For a prospective investor, the low ROIC is the central concern: the business is earning a thin return on the capital it deploys, which limits how much value each dollar of reinvestment creates. The FCF yield is a comparatively supportive counterpoint, but the pillar as a whole indicates weak fundamental economics.
• Whale 13F Flow: 14 / 20. The pillar reflects institutional accumulation and options positioning. This is a moderately positive reading, suggesting some sophisticated holders are building or maintaining exposure, though the source data does not break down the individual flows.
• Insider Conviction: 12 / 20. The pillar reflects SEC Form 4 and Congressional PTR cluster flow. This is a middling reading; it does not signal strong insider conviction in either direction.
• Macro Regime Fit: 13 / 20. The rating cites a beta of 1.1 and sector sensitivity. A beta slightly above the market implies modestly amplified moves relative to the broader market, which is a consideration in volatile rate or macro environments.
• Forensic Balance Sheet: 8 / 20. The rating cites an Altman Z-Score of 1.3, a Piotroski F-Score of 4/9, and a Debt/Equity ratio of 1.31. These are weak readings: the Altman figure sits in a range typically associated with elevated financial-distress risk, the Piotroski score is below the midpoint, and leverage is elevated.

Investor implications. The upside case rests on the cash-generation profile (the 8.57% FCF yield) and the institutional accumulation signal. The valuation tradeoff is significant: the market data shows a forward P/E of 34 and EV/EBITDA of 29.2 against negative trailing EPS of -1.3, meaning the price embeds expectations of a substantial earnings recovery that the historical fundamentals do not yet demonstrate. The combination of weak forensic metrics, thin ROIC, and high multiples is why the rating leans toward trim rather than accumulate. This is an analytical read of the provided data, not a recommendation for any individual.

The J.M. Smucker Company is a NYSE-listed issuer classified in the Consumer Staples sector and Packaged Foods industry. Per the company profile, it carries a market capitalization of $13.5B. The source data does not itemize product lines, customer segments, or revenue mix. Per the recent news wire, the Uncrustables brand is a referenced momentum driver, indicating it is a relevant product franchise for the company. Beyond that, the source data does not describe how the company makes money in detail.

Per the SEC financials, reported operating income moved from $1305.8M (FY 2023) to $-673.9M (FY 2024) before recovering to $360.2M (FY 2025), while net income was negative in both FY 2024 and FY 2025. Per the market data, the operating margin is 4%, the net margin is -1.5%, and the gross margin is 33.5%. The ROIC is 2.8%. Per the Roarable RQD rating, the Altman Z-Score is 1.3, the Piotroski F-Score is 4/9, and the Debt/Equity ratio is 1.31; debt has risen from $1735.8M (FY 2023) to $6841.3M (FY 2025), so the balance sheet posture is leveraged and the forensic indicators are weak. The FY 2023 revenue figure of $0.0M appears inconsistent with the other periods and is flagged for verification.

• Valuation focus (GREEN, CATALYST): A Yahoo Finance piece asks whether the recent rally remains undervalued, signaling active valuation debate.
• Uncrustables momentum (YELLOW, MARKET WIRE): A Yahoo Finance piece questions whether Uncrustables momentum can accelerate further, a product-level growth watch item.
• Dividend declaration (YELLOW, MARKET WIRE): A MarketBeat report covers a quarterly dividend of $1.12 per share.
• Analyst and forecast coverage (YELLOW, MARKET WIRE): A Simply Wall St piece covers stock forecasts and analyst predictions; the analyst data section itself is empty.
• Macro backdrop (YELLOW, MARKET WIRE): A TradingView piece covers the Fed holding rates steady amid inflation concerns, a rate-sensitive backdrop relevant to a staples issuer carrying elevated debt.
• Price and history (YELLOW, MARKET WIRE): A Yahoo Finance UK quote-and-history page provides generic market coverage.

The Butterfly Supply-Chain Graph reports no supply-chain links and no proprietary signals, so no butterfly-based catalyst is identified.

Per the Butterfly Supply-Chain Graph, the supply chain is "NONE," with no butterfly links and no proprietary signals. The source data therefore does not establish upstream suppliers, downstream customers, or sector correlations. The only sector context provided is the Consumer Staples / Packaged Foods classification. Investors should note that the absence of mapped dependencies is a data gap rather than evidence of an independent business. Interest-rate sensitivity is the one ripple the news wire touches on, given the elevated debt load of $6841.3M against the Fed-hold backdrop, and the macro-regime pillar's beta reading of 1.1 is consistent with that exposure.

• What is the company's trailing P/E? The source reports "Not available in source data," and the trailing EPS of -1.3 leaves valuation on a negative-earnings basis.
• Why does FY 2023 show $0.0M revenue while operating income is $1305.8M, and is that figure a reporting error?
• What drove the swing from operating income of $1305.8M (FY 2023) to $-673.9M (FY 2024), and what is the composition of the $6841.3M debt load?
• Which institutional holders and insiders are driving the 13F and Form 4 signals, given that the holders section is empty?
• How much of the Uncrustables franchise contributes to revenue and margins, and does it offset weakness elsewhere in the portfolio?